Drake Landing Solar Community
Home / Solar panels / Solar Roof Shingles or Solar Panels: Which Suits Your Roof?

Solar Roof Shingles or Solar Panels: Which Suits Your Roof?

Solar shingles are roofing material that also generates electricity, while solar panels are separate modules mounted on top of an existing roof. In most comparisons, solar panels win on cost per watt and efficiency, and solar shingles win on looks and on the chance to replace roofing and generate power in one job.

Last updated

What is the difference between solar shingles and solar panels?

Solar panels, in the usual rooftop form, are rectangular photovoltaic modules in aluminum frames. They sit on rails a few centimetres above the roof surface and are bolted through the roofing to the structure. The roof underneath keeps doing its job as the weather barrier.

Solar shingles, sometimes sold as a solar roof or solar roof tiles, are a form of building-integrated photovoltaics, or BIPV, a design in which solar power and building materials become one layer. Each shingle or tile has photovoltaic cells built in and is installed in the roof layer itself, the way ordinary asphalt shingles or tiles would be. They are wired together, and a roofer works alongside an electrician. The material is both the roofing and the generator, which is the appeal for a home owner who wants clean solar energy without a visible array on the roof.

Some products are thin strips that look like roof shingles, others are larger tiles, and some are flexible laminates stuck on the roof. Terms are loose, so the first job in any comparison is to ask what exactly is being offered and what standard of testing it has passed.

How do efficiency and power output compare?

Efficiency here means how much of the sunlight hitting the surface turns into electricity. Standard solar panels, especially the monocrystalline type described in the guide on monocrystalline solar panels, generally reach higher efficiency than solar shingles. Shingle cells are smaller, there are more gaps and joins between them, and the design has to double as roofing.

Heat plays a part as well. Solar cells lose a little output as they warm up. A panel on rails has air flowing underneath that carries heat away, while a shingle sits flush with the roof deck and runs hotter in summer. The difference is modest, but it adds to the efficiency gap in sunny weather.

A rough example makes the area problem clear. Say a household wants a 6 kW system. If solar panels deliver around 200 W per square metre of roof, that is about 30 m2. If solar shingles deliver around 130 W per square metre, the same 6 kW takes about 46 m2, which may be more roof than is available once chimneys, vents and shaded sections are subtracted. Those two figures are assumptions for illustration, not catalogue data. Real values vary, and the data sheet is the place to check. The efficiency guide explains how ratings are measured.

Shingles also tend to be installed over the whole roof plane for a uniform look, including parts that face poorly. That means some of the shingles produce little power, so the output per dollar is lower than the headline suggests. Panels can be placed on the best surfaces and left off the rest, as the roof requirements guide discusses.

Are solar shingles more expensive than solar panels?

Typically yes, per watt of generating capacity. Solar shingles generally cost more per watt than standard solar panels, because the item is more specialised, the market is smaller and installation is more labour-intensive. The difference can be substantial. Prices vary by region, brand and year, so only a written quote from a licensed installer settles the number, and a comparison should always use cost per watt rather than total price. The price-per-watt explainer shows how to do that and the guide on cost drivers lists what moves a quote.

The comparison is not straightforward, because solar shingles replace part of the roof. If the roof needs replacing anyway, some of the shingle cost offsets the roofing that would have been bought. If it does not, the shingles are a full roof replacement bought early, which is rarely the cheapest route. Owners considering this should ask the installer to split the quote into the roofing portion and the generating portion.

A practical test: price the same house three ways, a normal new roof plus solar panels, a roof that stays as it is plus solar panels, and solar shingles. Compare total installed cost per watt and the expected output over the same period.

Which is easier to install, repair and warrant?

Panels are the mainstream option, and installers across Canada know how to mount them. The installation steps are laid out in the guide on the solar panel installation process. Fewer firms install solar shingles, which can mean less choice, longer lead times and higher labour costs, and the roofing and electrical trades have to coordinate carefully.

Repairs differ too. A damaged panel can be unbolted and replaced on its own. A damaged shingle sits inside the roof layer and is wired into a circuit, so replacing it involves more steps and needs an installer familiar with that make. Leaks matter more for shingles, since the product is the weather barrier. The guide on roof leaks and flashing shows where the risk sits with rails and penetrations; with solar shingles that risk moves into the roof product itself.

Warranties usually split in two for both options: a materials warranty and a performance warranty on output. For shingles there may also be a roofing or weatherproofing warranty. Read each carefully, check who honours it if the manufacturer or installer closes, and note that shingle systems have a shorter track record in Canadian winters than rack-mounted solar panels. See the warranty guide for the wording to look for.

How long does a solar roof last in the long term?

A solar roof is judged on two clocks at once: how long the roofing material lasts and how long the cells keep generating. Asphalt shingles on a traditional roof commonly last somewhere around two to three decades, and rooftop panels carry output warranties of a similar length. A solar roof that combines both has to meet each clock, so the home energy system and the roof age together. If the cells decline faster than the weatherproofing, or the roofing wears out before the electronics, the whole system may need work. Ask for the expected degradation rate, the weatherproofing record and what swapping out a single solar shingle involves. The guide on panel lifespan and degradation explains the output side.

Which is better for a Canadian climate and roof?

Canadian conditions test any roof system: snow load, repeated freeze and thaw, ice dams, hail and wind. Rack-mounted solar panels have a long record in these conditions. Shingles are newer, so ask for evidence of cold-climate testing, snow shedding and certification to relevant building and electrical standards. Check availability too, since not every make is sold or supported in every province.

Roofs with a complex shape or many small faces can suit solar shingles, because they can follow the contours, while solar panels favour large, simple, south-facing planes. Heritage or neighbourhood design rules may also push an owner toward a low-profile option, so check with the municipality before choosing.

A reasonable decision path looks like this:

  1. If the roof is in good shape and cost per watt is the priority, solar panels are the usual choice.
  2. If the roof needs replacing soon and appearance matters a lot, get quotes for shingles alongside a new roof with solar panels, and compare both on a per-watt basis.
  3. If the roof is small, shaded or poorly oriented, check expected output before spending, whichever product is used.

Neither choice changes how net metering or interconnection works. Both connect to the grid through an inverter and need a permit and inspection.

Quick answers

Are solar shingles worth it?

They can be, mainly when a roof needs replacing anyway and appearance matters. On cost per watt and efficiency, standard solar panels usually come out ahead, so compare itemised quotes.

Do solar shingles last as long as solar panels?

Makers quote lifespans in the same range as solar panels, but solar shingles have a shorter field record. Ask for the materials and performance warranties in writing.

Can solar shingles be installed on an existing roof?

Usually they replace the roofing layer rather than sit on top, so the existing covering is removed first. Panels, by contrast, are mounted on top of a sound roof.

Do solar shingles work in snow and cold?

Cold itself helps output, but snow cover cuts production while it lasts. Ask about snow shedding and cold-climate testing for the specific product.

Where to verify

Programmes, rules and prices change. Before acting on anything you read here, check it at the source:

  • Natural Resources Canada: federal energy-efficiency and clean-energy pages: programme status, EnerGuide labels, technical background.
  • Your provincial electrical or building safety authority: permit, inspection and code requirements, including the edition of the Canadian Electrical Code in force.
  • Product certification marks: look for a recognised Canadian certification mark (for example CSA) on electrical and gas equipment.
  • Your electricity or gas utility: rates, connection requirements and any utility incentive.
  • A licensed professional in your province: sizing, safety and installation for your particular building; these guides are general background only.

dlsc.ca is an independent information site. It sells and installs nothing and gives no personal advice.

Part of the topic: Solar panels. See all guides on this topic.

More guides on this topic