How to know when a skylight needs replacing
Skylight replacement is worth planning when the glass has failed, the frame leaks around the flashing, or the unit is old enough that repairs keep returning. A new skylight is normally installed together with fresh flashing, because most leaks start at the roof seal rather than in the glass.
When does a skylight need replacing?
A skylight faces rain, snow load, ice and strong sun on a sloped surface, and it is cut into the roof. The seals, frame and flashing wear out at different rates.
Replacement usually beats repair in these cases:
- Failed glazing. Fog or moisture trapped between the panes means the sealed unit has lost its seal. The glass can sometimes be swapped alone, but on an old unit it is cheaper to change the whole skylight.
- Repeated leaks. If caulk and resealing have not held for more than a season or two, the frame or the flashing is likely beyond a patch.
- Cold draughts and heavy condensation. An old single-pane or poorly sealed unit leaks heat all winter.
- Stains and soft drywall. Brown rings on the ceiling around the shaft or mildew on the light well point to water that has been getting in for a while.
Is the leak really the skylight?
Not always. Water that shows up near a skylight can come from the flashing, from a roof leak further up the slope, from condensation on cold glass, or from a warm, humid room below. Condensation is common in winter and is often mistaken for a leak. It is discussed in our guide to winter condensation on windows.
A quick way to separate the causes is to note when it happens. Drips during rain or snowmelt point to flashing or the roof. Moisture on cold mornings with no rain points to condensation. A roofer or skylight installer can test with a hose and a second person inside. Our guide on roof leaks and flashing explains why the sealed edge around a roof opening is the usual weak point.
What kinds of replacement skylight are there?
The new skylight has to fit the existing roof opening, or the opening has to be reframed. That decision shapes everything else.
- Fixed skylights do not open. They are the simplest and usually the least likely to leak.
- Venting skylights open for fresh air and help clear moisture from bathrooms and kitchens. Some are operated by a rod, a crank or a small motor.
- Tubular skylights, sometimes called sun tunnels, bring light down a reflective tube through the attic. They suit small, dark rooms and need a much smaller roof opening.
Look at the glazing too. Double or triple panes, low-emissivity coatings and gas fills all reduce heat loss, and our guides on low-e windows and ENERGY STAR certified windows explain what those labels mean. Ask for the unit's U-factor: a lower number loses less heat.
How is a skylight replaced?
The steps are similar for most homes.
- The installer measures the opening and the rough framing, checks for water damage and confirms the new skylight's size.
- Roofing around the skylight is lifted, and the old skylight and flashing are removed.
- Damaged framing or sheathing is repaired, which is where hidden rot is sometimes found.
- The new unit is set and fastened, then flashed in layers so water runs over each joint rather than into it. Shingles or other roofing are put back over the flashing.
- The inside is finished, including insulation around the light well, air sealing, and drywall or trim.
Insulating and air sealing the shaft matters as much as the unit. A bright, well-glazed skylight can still feel cold if the shaft is bare. Our air sealing guide and attic insulation guide cover the details around the opening.
What affects the cost and who should do the work?
No single national price is reliable. Costs depend on the unit type and size, whether the roof opening changes, roof pitch and height, the roofing material, interior finishing, and how much hidden damage is found. A like-for-like swap in the same opening is typically the cheapest case. Moving or enlarging the opening is more work, and it may involve structural framing that needs a permit. Ask for written quotes that itemize the unit, flashing, roofing work and interior finishing.
Choose a contractor who handles roofing as well as the unit, since the flashing joins the two. Rules on permits vary by municipality, so check with your local building department. For possible rebates on windows and skylights, see window rebates in Canada, and confirm current terms with the Government of Canada energy-efficiency pages and your provincial energy ministry before buying.
Quick answers
How long does a skylight last?
Many skylights last for a few decades, but the seals and flashing often wear out sooner than the frame. The manufacturer's documentation gives the expected life and warranty terms for your model.
Can I replace just the glass in a skylight?
Sometimes, if the frame is sound and the supplier makes a matching sealed unit. On an older skylight with a worn frame or flashing, replacing the whole unit usually makes more sense.
Does a new skylight save energy?
A modern, well-sealed skylight with better glazing usually loses less heat than an old or failed one, though shaft insulation and air sealing matter too.
Do I need a permit to replace a skylight?
A same-size swap may not need one, while changing the opening or the roof framing often does. Check with your municipal building department before work starts.