Drake Landing Solar Community
Home / Solar panels / Wind vs Solar Power: Which Source Suits a Home?

Wind vs Solar Power: Which Source Suits a Home?

For most Canadian houses, solar energy is the simpler renewable power source. Wind energy from a small turbine only makes sense on open, exposed land with steady wind, and it needs a tall tower, a permit and regular maintenance.

Last updated

What is the difference between solar and wind energy?

Both are renewable energy sources that produce electricity without burning fossil fuels, and both can feed a house through an inverter and the utility meter. The difference is what they harvest. Solar power comes from panels that turn sunlight directly into electricity with no moving parts. Wind power comes from a wind turbine that turns moving air into electricity through spinning blades and a generator.

That one difference drives almost everything else in the solar vs wind energy comparison, from efficiency to cost. Sunlight is predictable by season and hour. Wind is local, gusty and strongly affected by trees, buildings and terrain. If you want the basics first, the guide to solar energy basics in Canada covers how panels work.

What is a capacity factor, and how do solar and wind compare?

Capacity factor is the share of its nameplate rating a system actually delivers over twelve months. A 5 kW array that produced the equivalent of full power for 1,000 hours has a factor of about 11 percent (1,000 divided by 8,760 hours). It shows how well a power source uses its rating, not how much it costs.

Roughly speaking, rooftop solar in Canada often lands somewhere around 11 to 17 percent, helped by long summer days and clear, cold winter air. Large utility-scale wind turbines in good locations is frequently quoted at about 30 to 40 percent. That looks like a clear win for wind energy, but it applies to big machines on tall towers in well-chosen windy sites. A small wind turbine on a residential lot usually does far worse, because the wind there is slower and more turbulent. Wind power also depends on speed cubed in principle: when the wind speed doubles, the energy in the wind rises roughly eight times, so a modest gain in average speed makes a large difference to a turbine, while a modest gain in sunlight changes a solar array's output in a more linear way.

For the solar side, peak sun hours are the practical measure, and a solar production estimate shows how installers translate them into kilowatt-hours per year.

What site requirements does a small wind turbine have?

The site decides everything for wind energy, and installation of a tower is the hard part. A small wind system needs a fairly steady annual average wind speed, commonly cited as around 4 to 5 metres per second or better at the height of the rotor. It also needs clear air. A widely used rule of thumb puts the bottom of the blades roughly 9 metres (30 feet) above any obstacle within about 150 metres. That usually means a tower of 20 to 40 metres.

Practical requirements follow from that, and the technology is less forgiving than panels:

  • Open land, such as a farm or acreage, rather than a town lot with trees and neighbours.
  • Zoning, height and setback rules, which are set by the municipality and differ widely. Some urban areas do not allow towers at all.
  • A tower foundation, guy wires or a freestanding mast, and access for crane or tilt-down service.
  • Noise and shadow flicker considerations for neighbours.
  • Utility interconnection approval if the system is grid-tied.

Solar panels have shorter requirements: a roof or ground area with decent exposure, not much shade, and a structure that can carry the load. See solar panel roof requirements and the best direction to face panels.

Which costs more? Pros, cons and maintenance

Prices vary by region and over time, and quotes decide, but the pattern is steady. Small wind systems typically cost more per kilowatt installed than rooftop solar, once the tower, foundation and electrical work are included. Solar prices have fallen over the past decade, while small wind has not followed the same curve. Solar energy pros: quiet, scalable, little upkeep, efficient use of an existing roof. Solar cons: nothing at night and little in a December cloud. Wind power pros: a turbine can generate electricity at night and in storms. Wind cons: noise, neighbour concerns and higher maintenance costs for the wind turbine and its tower. The main cost drivers are system size, tower height, site access and local labour. See solar panel cost in Canada for the solar side.

Maintenance also differs. Solar panels have no moving parts and are mostly left alone apart from occasional cleaning or snow clearing. A wind turbine has bearings, blades and a generator that wear, and it may need an annual inspection. Panels often carry output warranties of 25 years, while the working life of a small turbine depends heavily on how often it spins in rough weather. Compare these terms in writing before judging cost, and read how long solar panels last.

When can wind and solar work together?

Canadian winters have short, dim days, but they are often windier than summer. On a rural property with a good wind resource, a hybrid solar and wind power system can balance seasons: panels carry the long summer days and a turbine adds wind energy on stormy winter nights. Technology for pairing both renewable sources through one inverter and battery is well established. Off-grid cabins and farms, where a battery bank and sometimes a generator are in play, are the usual setting. The guides to off-grid solar and grid-tied vs off-grid explain those trade-offs.

For a grid-tied house the case is thinner, because the utility already smooths the supply of electricity. Check the local rules, including net metering, through the provincial energy ministry and the local utility, because they set what you are paid or credited for exported power.

The comparison is not limited to electricity. A neighbourhood-scale example from Alberta shows another route: how Drake Landing used solar heat rather than power, storing summer sun for winter. See also solar thermal vs solar PV.

Quick answers

Is wind or solar power better for a house in Canada?

For most houses solar is better, because it works on a normal roof, needs no tower and has little upkeep. Wind energy can win on open rural land with strong, steady wind and permission for a tall tower.

Can a small wind turbine power a whole house?

Only in the right location, and it is sized against the household's annual use. In turbulent air near buildings and trees, output is often much lower than the rating suggests, so a wind resource assessment comes first.

Do I need a permit for a home wind turbine?

Usually yes. Turbine height, setbacks, noise and electrical connection are covered by municipal bylaws and utility rules, so ask the local planning office and the utility before spending money.

What is a capacity factor?

It is the percentage of a system's maximum possible output that it actually delivers across a full cycle of seasons. Wind and solar have very different typical values, which is why it is used to compare them.

Where to verify

Programmes, rules and prices change. Before acting on anything you read here, check it at the source:

  • Natural Resources Canada: federal energy-efficiency and clean-energy pages: programme status, EnerGuide labels, technical background.
  • Your provincial electrical or building safety authority: permit, inspection and code requirements, including the edition of the Canadian Electrical Code in force.
  • Product certification marks: look for a recognised Canadian certification mark (for example CSA) on electrical and gas equipment.
  • Your electricity or gas utility: rates, connection requirements and any utility incentive.
  • A licensed professional in your province: sizing, safety and installation for your particular building; these guides are general background only.

dlsc.ca is an independent information site. It sells and installs nothing and gives no personal advice.

Part of the topic: Solar panels. See all guides on this topic.

More guides on this topic